Jump to content
You need to play a total of 10 battles to post in this section.
TheNPUKy

Do Soviet BBs have good vertical dispersion?

1 comment in this topic

Recommended Posts

9
[AUDI]
Member
22 posts
11,902 battles

Probably, Yes. 
Soviet BBs likely have a tight vertical dispersion which enables a player to hit the broadside of an enemy ship effectively.

I have tested in a training mode. Here are the digitized plots of the salvos (100 hits) on the surface at 10 and 15 km of distances. Sinop (Soviet Tier 7 BB) significantly outperforms Ashitaka and Bismarck (=Gneisenau) in vertical dispersion while its horizontal dispersion is the worst.
Note that it is an apparent vertical dispersion projected onto the horizontal surface. The true vertical dispersion is the dispersion on a vertical plane which is hard to test.

Sinop-Ahistaka-Bismarck-10km.thumb.png.67c52243b8c5cb19a882babe183ba4f2.png
Fig. 1. The results of firing at 10 km with the three ships. The shells were fired from the bottom to top. Sinop outperforms others with the tight concentration of salvos at the centre of the y-axis. Ashitaka performs best in horizontal dispersion thanks to both good sigma and small max dispersion (See the table).  However in terms of vertical dispersion, Ashitaka falls to the bottom probably because IJN BBs are supposed to have bad vertical dispersion (source). Bismarck has a long tail of dispersion due to its low-flying shells.

Sinop-Ahistaka-Bismarck-15km.thumb.png.c5dea91b6a26c0df053e7e58e9deea81.png
Fig. 2. The results of firing at 15 km with the three ships. The Sinop still leads the rivals in vertical dispersion while its horizontal dispersion is exceptionally bad probably due to the combination of broad max dispersion and low sigma. 

  Sigma Max radius in horizontal dispersion (x2.0 when it is not locked) Impact angle (via wowsft.com)  
Sinop (10km) 1.6 150 m 8.3 degree  
Ashitaka (10km) 1.8 156 m 7.7 degree  
Bismarck (10km) 1.8 164 m 6.7 degree  
Sinop (15km) 1.6 210.5 m 16.0 degree  
Ashitaka (15km) 1.8 192.0 m 14.9 degree  
Bismarck (15km) 1.8 213.0 m 12.2 degree  


Methods

  1. Hopping into the training mode
  2. Firing onto the cap area cone at the desired distance
  3. Screengrabbing the salvo from above with replays
  4. Digitizing them in GIS software
  5. Some math and coding to normalize them

howdidyoudothat2.thumb.jpg.3f0c1797236c26f652b9bcb7c8289979.jpg
Please never ask me to do 1000 hits :P

 

Edited by TheNPUKy
  • Cool 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

×