Jump to content
You need to play a total of 10 battles to post in this section.
27000ants

Tier 5 Elimination Thread, SEA edition

57 comments in this topic

Recommended Posts

22
[KNCOL]
Member
404 posts
10,952 battles

So there I was, poking the EU forums, and I found this guy's post and decided to shamelessly rip it off do a cross comparison between the meta on different servers: http://forum.worldofwarships.eu/index.php?/topic/66470-elimination-thread-number-two-tier-v/

 

Here is the list of ships:

Starting list:

Bogue (2/0/1): 15

Bogue (1/1/0): 15

Bogue (0/1/2): 15

New York: 15

Texas: 15

Omaha: 15

Marblehead: 15

Nicholas: 15

Zuiho (1/1/2): 15

Zuiho (1/2/1): 15

Kongo+ARP clones: 15

Furutaka: 15

Kamikaze/Fujin: 15

Minekaze: 15

Gnevny: 15

Gremy: 15

Kirov: 15

Murmansk: 15

Kazny Krym: 15

Konig: 15

Konigsberg: 15

Emerald: 15

 

Basically the rule is that when you post, you choose the best ship and give it one point and choose the worst ship and subtract 3 points. When doing so you must explain your choice. The next guy follows on from where you left off. When a ship hits 0 points, it is eliminated and removed from further consideration. Copy-paste the list when you make the edits please!

 

List of ships in order of elimination:

Krasny Krym

Marblehead

Emerald

Bogue (0/1/2)

Omaha

Edited by 27000ants

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
283
[LBAS]
Member
2,640 posts
8,039 battles

+1 Kamikaze = ninja torps FTW

 

-3 Kransy Krym = need explanation? him being in the list is already a sin

 


do i need to copy the list?

 

Here is the list of ships:

Starting list:

Bogue (2/0/1): 15

Bogue (1/1/0): 15

Bogue (0/1/2): 15

New York: 15

Texas: 15

Omaha: 15

Marblehead: 15

Nicholas: 15

Zuiho (1/1/2): 15

Zuiho (1/2/1): 15

Kongo+ARP clones: 15

Furutaka: 15

Kamikaze/Fujin: 16

Minekaze: 15

Gnevny: 15

Gremy: 15

Kirov: 15

Murmansk: 15

Kazny Krym: 12

Konig: 15

Konigsberg: 15

Emerald: 15

Edited by XP_On

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Member
223 posts
3,340 battles

+1 Minekaze : Fast, nice concealment, nice enough gun

-3 crispy cream : .....this ship is just wtf..... 

 

Bogue (2/0/1): 15

Bogue (1/1/0): 15

Bogue (0/1/2): 15

New York: 15

Texas: 15

Omaha: 15

Marblehead: 15

Nicholas: 15

Zuiho (1/1/2): 15

Zuiho (1/2/1): 15

Kongo+ARP clones: 15

Furutaka: 15

Kamikaze/Fujin: 16

Minekaze: 16

Gnevny: 15

Gremy: 15

Kirov: 15

Murmansk: 15

Kazny Krym: 9

Konig: 15

Konigsberg: 15

Emerald: 15

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
53
[CHIPS]
Member
563 posts
5,800 battles

 

 

Bogue (2/0/1): 15

Bogue (1/1/0): 16

Bogue (0/1/2): 15

New York: 15

Texas: 15

Omaha: 15

Marblehead: 12

Nicholas: 15

Zuiho (1/1/2): 15

Zuiho (1/2/1): 15

Kongo+ARP clones: 15

Furutaka: 15

Kamikaze/Fujin: 16

Minekaze: 16

Gnevny: 15

Gremy: 15

Kirov: 15

Murmansk: 15

Kazny Krym: 9

Konig: 15

Konigsberg: 15

Emerald: 15

 

+1 Bogue (1/1/0). Best CV at t5, the 1/1/0 is the most flexible loadout she has.

-3 Marblehead. Short ranged floating citadel.

 

 

Edited by Admiral_Turing

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Member
1,169 posts

+1 Furutaka : Extremely big guns, will totally dominate at top tier games.

 

-3 Kransy Krym : ........... [bleep] [bleeeeeep] [bleep]


Bogue (2/0/1): 15

Bogue (1/1/0): 16

Bogue (0/1/2): 15

New York: 15

Texas: 15

Omaha: 15

Marblehead: 12

Nicholas: 15

Zuiho (1/1/2): 15

Zuiho (1/2/1): 15

Kongo+ARP clones: 15

Furutaka: 16

Kamikaze/Fujin: 16

Minekaze: 16

Gnevny: 15

Gremy: 15

Kirov: 15

Murmansk: 15

Kazny Krym: 6

Konig: 15

Konigsberg: 15

Emerald: 15

Edited by RisaFujiyama

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Member
211 posts
9,333 battles

+1 Gnevny for wonderful arc, stealthy as its peers with CE, robust ship and high skill floor
-3 Emerald because her firepower is seriously underwhelming, armored terribly and cannot protect herself against other cruisers. The citadel size is also suitable for new BB commanders to practice Devastating Strike

 

Bogue (2/0/1): 15

Bogue (1/1/0): 16

Bogue (0/1/2): 15

New York: 15

Texas: 15

Omaha: 15

Marblehead: 12

Nicholas: 15

Zuiho (1/1/2): 15

Zuiho (1/2/1): 15

Kongo+ARP clones: 15

Furutaka: 16

Kamikaze/Fujin: 16

Minekaze: 16

Gnevny: 16

Gremy: 15

Kirov: 15

Murmansk: 15

Kazny Krym: 6

Konig: 15

Konigsberg: 15

Emerald: 12

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Member
419 posts
4,408 battles

+1 gremy: OP torp, powerful gun and good HP

-3 Krasniy: a tier 4 given some minor change and put into tier 5. really?

 

Bogue (2/0/1): 15

Bogue (1/1/0): 16

Bogue (0/1/2): 15

New York: 15

Texas: 15

Omaha: 15

Marblehead: 12

Nicholas: 15

Zuiho (1/1/2): 15

Zuiho (1/2/1): 15

Kongo+ARP clones: 15

Furutaka: 16

Kamikaze/Fujin: 16

Minekaze: 16

Gnevny: 16

Gremy: 16

Kirov: 15

Murmansk: 15

Kazny Krym: 3

Konig: 15

Konigsberg: 15

Emerald: 12

Edited by Arcane_Dream

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Member
68 posts
3,838 battles

+1 Konigsberg: the overall good AP guns plus excellent range with torps.

-3 Furutaka: stock loadout is a pain to use

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
759
[LEAK]
Member
2,500 posts
1,557 battles

What if you're a weirdo like me and can neither find a terrible ship on the list nor have a single favourite one?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Beta Tester
1,043 posts
4,300 battles

+1 Konig: Underrated BB

-3 Gnevny: Cheap, weak, trying hard Gremy.

 

 

Bogue (2/0/1): 15

Bogue (1/1/0): 16

Bogue (0/1/2): 15

New York: 15

Texas: 15

Omaha: 15

Marblehead: 12

Nicholas: 15

Zuiho (1/1/2): 15

Zuiho (1/2/1): 15

Kongo+ARP clones: 15

Furutaka: 13

Kamikaze/Fujin: 16

Minekaze: 16

Gnevny: 13

Gremy: 16

Kirov: 15

Murmansk: 15

Kazny Krym: 3

Konig: 16

Konigsberg: 16

Emerald: 12

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1,153
[BLUMR]
Moderator
4,163 posts
1,924 battles

Finish him!

 

+1 Kirov, because the stalinium guns are pretty awesome. -3 Krasny Krym, and I don't really need to explain why.

 

Bogue (2/0/1): 15

Bogue (1/1/0): 16

Bogue (0/1/2): 15

New York: 15

Texas: 15

Omaha: 15

Marblehead: 12

Nicholas: 15

Zuiho (1/1/2): 15

Zuiho (1/2/1): 15

Kongo+ARP clones: 15

Furutaka: 13

Kamikaze/Fujin: 16

Minekaze: 16

Gnevny: 13

Gremy: 16

Kirov: 16

Murmansk: 15

Krazny Krym: 0

Konig: 16

Konigsberg: 16

Emerald: 12

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
3
[ULAG]
Super Tester_
234 posts
8,863 battles

 

+1 Konig: the best anti-cruiser :P
-3 Emrald: Worst cruiser probably imo and the +2 always MM

 

 

Bogue (2/0/1): 15

Bogue (1/1/0): 16

Bogue (0/1/2): 15

New York: 15

Texas: 15

Omaha: 15

Marblehead: 12

Nicholas: 15

Zuiho (1/1/2): 15

Zuiho (1/2/1): 15

Kongo+ARP clones: 15

Furutaka: 13

Kamikaze/Fujin: 16

Minekaze: 16

Gnevny: 13

Gremy: 16

Kirov: 16

Murmansk: 15

Konig: 17

Konigsberg: 16

Emerald: 12

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
34
[TDA]
Member
173 posts
11,276 battles

 

Kamikaze/Fujin: +1 fast torps, good guns, stealth and speed, whats not to love! Also immune to upcoming Minekaze nerfs.  Clubbers go to DD.

 

Damm Krispy already gone! got a kracken in you once but that was all me, not you... :-). Guess ....

 

Marblehead -3; The ugly sister compared to Omaha and Murmansk

 

 

 

Bogue (2/0/1): 15

Bogue (1/1/0): 16

Bogue (0/1/2): 15

New York: 15

Texas: 15

Omaha: 15

Marblehead: 9

Nicholas: 15

Zuiho (1/1/2): 15

Zuiho (1/2/1): 15

Kongo+ARP clones: 15

Furutaka: 13

Kamikaze/Fujin: 17

Minekaze: 16

Gnevny: 13

Gremy: 16

Kirov: 16

Murmansk: 15

Konig: 17

Konigsberg: 16

Emerald: 12

 

 

Edited by Bitrot

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
22
[KNCOL]
Member
404 posts
10,952 battles

 

Bogue (2/0/1): 15

Bogue (1/1/0): 17

Bogue (0/1/2): 12

New York: 15

Texas: 15

Omaha: 15

Marblehead: 9

Nicholas: 15

Zuiho (1/1/2): 15

Zuiho (1/2/1): 15

Kongo+ARP clones: 15

Furutaka: 13

Kamikaze/Fujin: 17

Minekaze: 16

Gnevny: 13

Gremy: 16

Kirov: 16

Murmansk: 15

Konig: 17

Konigsberg: 16

Emerald: 12

 

+1 to Bogue (1/1/0) due to it being the only American carrier until tier 7 to have more than 1 full replacement for its torpedo squads in addition to its flexibility (imagine a Saipan at tier 5).

-3 to Bogue (0/1/2) due to it being just sad. 2/0/1 still works at this tier because Zuiho only has 1 squad of fighters, so this is the last tier that american AS can counter IJN AS

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2,452
[REPOI]
Member
6,010 posts
24,722 battles

+1 to grem because that ship is damn op, -3 to omaha because everything that floats can overmatch it

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Member
288 posts
5,590 battles

+1 Gnevny: First proper Russian DD gunboat in the line and very underrated

-3 Emerald: So, so fragile, and far too situational to ever be consistently fun

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
22
[KNCOL]
Member
404 posts
10,952 battles

 

Bogue (2/0/1): 15

Bogue (1/1/0): 17

Bogue (0/1/2): 12

New York: 15

Texas: 15

Omaha: 12

Marblehead: 9

Nicholas: 15

Zuiho (1/1/2): 15

Zuiho (1/2/1): 15

Kongo+ARP clones: 15

Furutaka: 13

Kamikaze/Fujin: 17

Minekaze: 16

Gnevny: 14

Gremy: 17

Kirov: 16

Murmansk: 15

Konig: 17

Konigsberg: 16

Emerald: 9

 

As it currently stands

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
26
[BOTES]
Beta Tester
106 posts
3,362 battles

+1 Kongo (ARP): Nimble (for a BB), good range, good guns, decent AA.

-3 Omaha: Probably not the ship's fault, but I just can't make it work.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
37
[PBKAC]
Member
271 posts
7,615 battles

+1 Konig. Although the dispersion will make you pull your hair out - properly played, you're tough as nails for this tier.

 

-3 Marblehead - sorry you're just a poorer ranged Omaha.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
13
[RWBY]
Member
75 posts
5,169 battles

+1 Omaha. Evasive as hell and bringer of flames.

 

-3 Nicholas. Only reason anyone puts up with it is the glorious Farragut at the end.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
34
[UWU]
Member
533 posts
5,092 battles

+1 kamikaze gud stuff

-3 bogue 0/1/2 , just who wants to even.......


js copy n paste and edit abit dun be lazy...

 


Bogue (2/0/1): 15

Bogue (1/1/0): 17

Bogue (0/1/2): 9

New York: 15

Texas: 15

Omaha: 10

Marblehead: 6

Nicholas: 12

Zuiho (1/1/2): 15

Zuiho (1/2/1): 15

Kongo+ARP clones: 16

Furutaka: 10

Kamikaze/Fujin: 18

Minekaze: 16

Gnevny: 14

Gremy: 17

Kirov: 16

Murmansk: 15

Konig: 17

Konigsberg: 16

Emerald: 9
 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
41
[POI]
Super Tester_
202 posts
12,926 battles

+1 Gremy - Str8 up OP 

- 3 Marblehead - No, just no, her range hurts and will be easily deleted by BB's

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Bogue (2/0/1): 15

Bogue (1/1/0): 17

Bogue (0/1/2): 9

New York: 15

Texas: 15

Omaha: 10

Marblehead: 3

Nicholas: 12

Zuiho (1/1/2): 15

Zuiho (1/2/1): 15

Kongo+ARP clones: 16

Furutaka: 10

Kamikaze/Fujin: 18

Minekaze: 16

Gnevny: 14

Gremy: 18

Kirov: 16

Murmansk: 15

Konig: 17

Konigsberg: 16

Emerald: 9

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
31
[BLUMR]
Member
193 posts
4,961 battles

 

New York +1 because 10 guns.

Emerald -3 because it has no business seeing tier 7

 

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Bogue (2/0/1): 15

Bogue (1/1/0): 17

Bogue (0/1/2): 9

New York: 16

Texas: 15

Omaha: 10

Marblehead: 3

Nicholas: 12

Zuiho (1/1/2): 15

Zuiho (1/2/1): 15

Kongo+ARP clones: 16

Furutaka: 10

Kamikaze/Fujin: 18

Minekaze: 16

Gnevny: 14

Gremy: 18

Kirov: 16

Murmansk: 15

Konig: 17

Konigsberg: 16

Emerald: 6

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Video Contributor, Beta Tester, Clantest Coordinator
2,651 posts
13,245 battles

Kirov +1 because REPORTING!

Bogue (0/1/2) -3 I don't like 012 for low tier or don't have any FT to cover friendly 

-----------------------------------------------------------

Bogue (2/0/1): 15

Bogue (1/1/0): 17

Bogue (0/1/2): 6

New York: 16

Texas: 15

Omaha: 10

Marblehead: 3

Nicholas: 12

Zuiho (1/1/2): 15

Zuiho (1/2/1): 15

Kongo+ARP clones: 16

Furutaka: 10

Kamikaze/Fujin: 18

Minekaze: 16

Gnevny: 14

Gremy: 18

Kirov: 17

Murmansk: 15

Konig: 17

Konigsberg: 16

Emerald: 6

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

×