Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
You need to play a total of 10 battles to post in this section.
antares031

Which ship is the origin of german cruiser Roon?

38 comments in this topic

Recommended Posts

Member
17 posts
1,580 battles

KE8Wx0F.jpg

 

I bet this topic is debatable, but I want know the true source of this made-up german cruiser, Tier IX Roon.

 

Apparently, the russian community suggests that this ships is based on the P-class panzerschiffe(http://goo.gl/1IT7hT), while there are only few references of P-class to this ship. First of all, as I mentioned, P-Class was a "panzerschiffe" which are armed with at least 11" as main armament. Plus, the overall design of Roon is similar to light cruiser Nurnberg rather than P-class. The layout of main armaments(one turret at bow, two turrets at stern), shape of superstructure and funnel is pretty much identical to Nurnberg. And the developers put some reference of other WW2 ships, including P-class, to this fictional ship. They took the 8" as main armaments from Admiral Hipper and upgraded them from twin to triple, took the side secondary armaments from Deutschland, and took the idea from P-class that placing twin 5.9" turret right behind the front main armament. Overall, this ship is a heavy cruiser version of Nurnberg with adding references from various german cruisers.

 

Currently, there's no clear explanation about it in the game client. If the developers made a fictional ship based on the projected ship, I suggest to put some explanations about it in the game. What's your opinion about this one? Is Roon based on P-class panzerschiffe, or other ship? If there's a official statement from Wargaming about this topic, it will be appreciated.

 

P.S.: Tier X is obviously based on Admiral Hipper class. There's no doubt about it.

  • Cool 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1,454
[VOR]
Super Tester
1,398 posts
15,226 battles

KE8Wx0F.jpg

 

I bet this topic is debatable, but I want know the true source of this made-up german cruiser, Tier IX Roon.

 

Apparently, the russian community suggests that this ships is based on the P-class panzerschiffe(http://goo.gl/1IT7hT), while there are only few references of P-class to this ship. First of all, as I mentioned, P-Class was a "panzerschiffe" which are armed with at least 11" as main armament. Plus, the overall design of Roon is similar to light cruiser Nurnberg rather than P-class. The layout of main armaments(one turret at bow, two turrets at stern), shape of superstructure and funnel is pretty much identical to Nurnberg. And the developers put some reference of other WW2 ships, including P-class, to this fictional ship. They took the 8" as main armaments from Admiral Hipper and upgraded them from twin to triple, took the side secondary armaments from Deutschland, and took the idea from P-class that placing twin 5.9" turret right behind the front main armament. Overall, this ship is a heavy cruiser version of Nurnberg with adding references from various german cruisers.

 

Currently, there's no clear explanation about it in the game client. If the developers made a fictional ship based on the projected ship, I suggest to put some explanations about it in the game. What's your opinion about this one? Is Roon based on P-class panzerschiffe, or other ship? If there's a official statement from Wargaming about this topic, it will be appreciated.

 

P.S.: Tier X is obviously based on Admiral Hipper class. There's no doubt about it.

 

Fiction ship heh, love how devs decided to put 1 secondary in the front lmao.

But German triple guns are beast.

Hipper is stupid with the Twin guns :(

Edited by R3negade
  • Cool 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
378
[REPOI]
Member
1,643 posts
4,905 battles

Prinz Eugen? Stupid?

  • Cool 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
654
[POI]
Beta Tester
4,888 posts
9,936 battles

Prinz Eugen? Stupid?

 

I also usually called Hipper as a Eugen because their are basically the same class and Prinz Eugen kinda more famous :D:D:D 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
334
[BRU]
Super Tester
1,689 posts

 

Fiction ship heh, love how devs decided to put 1 secondary in the front lmao.

But German triple guns are beast.

Hipper is stupid with the Twin guns :(

 

Sorry for the Hipper being stupid with her dual mount turrets then.

 

As for Roon, the layout of the hull is really similar to the P but the A-XY layout lugging about may be something of note since P was made to carry 11 inch guns so it won't be a big surprise if the hull was projected with the same layout. Remember that Scharnhorst's hull could be theoretically be lugged with 15 inch guns with a little bit of retrofitting for that matter. Its likely two things for this heavy cruiser: its an original concept like the patented E-50M or there were actually design studies within the paper ships and for the latter however, remember that even Montana had a LOT of design feasibility studies, one of which was the BB-65-2 which is being touted as the pinnacle of the 'fast battleship' thought since Montana was... well... not a really fast ship.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1,454
[VOR]
Super Tester
1,398 posts
15,226 battles

 

I also usually called Hipper as a Eugen because their are basically the same class and Prinz Eugen kinda more famous :D:D:D 

 

stop browsing forum and work LOL
  • Cool 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1,454
[VOR]
Super Tester
1,398 posts
15,226 battles

Prinz Eugen? Stupid?

 

Well the ship itself isn't really stupid and quite nice, just personally dislike(get bored) with twin guns :v

 

The problem is the German HE shell and you get match up against Mogamis :<

and weak amour makes you vulnerable from HE hits.

Edited by R3negade
  • Cool 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
654
[POI]
Beta Tester
4,888 posts
9,936 battles

 

stop browsing forum and work LOL

 

Im doing it atm you know, Need to leave office early since this is Friday :D:D:D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Member
423 posts
3,200 battles

I think this is the origin of Roon

Q8DEPwi.jpg

 

with the men on it are armed with RPG, and sinking USS Cole :trollface:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1,454
[VOR]
Super Tester
1,398 posts
15,226 battles

 

Im doing it atm you know, Need to leave office early since this is Friday :D:D:D

 

My Yamato is waiting :>
  • Cool 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Member
17 posts
1,580 battles

As for Roon, the layout of the hull is really similar to the P but the A-XY layout lugging about may be something of note since P was made to carry 11 inch guns so it won't be a big surprise if the hull was projected with the same layout.

 

I thought the layout of Roon is sized-up version of Nurnberg considering that it has similar main armament placement; in the end, main armament is the identity of the ship IMHO. I agree that some parts of hull are may based on the one from P-class, but I'm not sure about it. Plus, keep in mind that P-class had two funnels that are separated with some spaces between them. It will make a different layout of engine room compare to the Roon which has similar funnel layout of Nurnberg or Admiral Hipper class.

 

 

 

I think this is the origin of Roon

Q8DEPwi.jpg

 

with the men on it are armed with RPG, and sinking USS Cole :trollface:

 

......Mother of god?! :ohmy:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
334
[BRU]
Super Tester
1,689 posts

 

I thought the layout of Roon is sized-up version of Nurnberg considering that it has similar main armament placement; in the end, main armament is the identity of the ship IMHO. I agree that some parts of hull are may based on the one from P-class, but I'm not sure about it. Plus, keep in mind that P-class had two funnels that are separated with some spaces between them. It will make a different layout of engine room compare to the Roon which has similar funnel layout of Nurnberg or Admiral Hipper class.

 

The funnels were merged into a single large funnel however just like the ships Fuso and Nagato when they were retrofitted. The boilers or the turbines likely moved a bit for the new placement but the hull doesn't look like it was changed and besides, Nurnberg wasn't the first A-XY layout for a ship they did since I think Koenigsberg did it first within their cruisers.

Edited by EvyL

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Beta Tester
1,422 posts
41 battles

I think this is the origin of Roon

Q8DEPwi.jpg

 

with the men on it are armed with RPG, and sinking USS Cole :trollface:

 

they see me rowing they hating

shooting 18 inch shell at me

 

alothough tier X: Graf Spee would be nice~~~

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1,454
[VOR]
Super Tester
1,398 posts
15,226 battles

I think he's not referring the ship as "stupid" but someone here I think. :v

 

no :v
  • Cool 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
80
[KMS-A]
Modder
379 posts
459 battles
On 11/6/2015 at 11:14 AM, jchen8792 said:

I think this is the origin of Roon

Q8DEPwi.jpg

 

with the men on it are armed with RPG, and sinking USS Cole :trollface:

That boat even came with a washed up Baltic Kriegsmarine camo.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
433
[151ST]
Member
1,313 posts
6,692 battles

Is this the Necro of the year so far?

I ended up skipping Room, I do enjoy the Hindy though and wish her AA was actually good again... I remember when she was an AA monster!

I don't mind WG making up theoretical for 9 and 10 to complete lines as long as the ships make sense... Particularly in view of the fact that many Navies tapered off around T8 simply due to the war wrapping up and/or existing designs being fit for purpose and/or being eclipsed by CVs.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
22
[LLBC]
Member
163 posts
5,905 battles

And I'm just so surprised to see Melon for a sec.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1,786
[LBAS]
Modder
5,710 posts
33,888 battles
On 6/25/2019 at 6:55 AM, LordTyphoon said:

Why necro

unable to understand :Smile_facepalm:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
167
[KCSEA]
Member
226 posts
6,515 battles
17 hours ago, HeidimarieW said:

And I'm just so surprised to see Melon for a sec.

Melon will always be alive in our hearts

also :pat:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sign in to follow this  

×